السبت، 5 يوليو 2008

Message to U.S. Preceded Nuclear Declaration by North Korea

Sphere: Related Content
Washington Post

Message to U.S. Preceded Nuclear Declaration by North Korea

By Glenn Kessler
Wednesday, July 2, 2008

Just days before North Korea delivered to China last week its long-awaited declaration on its plutonium-based nuclear programs, Pyongyang privately acknowledged the United States' long-standing concerns about alleged uranium-enrichment activities and possible proliferation to Syria, U.S. and Asian officials said yesterday.

U.S. officials have made only cryptic references to Pyongyang's private message to Washington, in part because it represents a significant scaling back of the administration's goals and ambitions for North Korea's declaration.

Originally, the administration had promised that Pyongyang would come clean on its uranium-enrichment activities, not merely "acknowledge" U.S. concerns. The unusual move to separate vexing issues from the declaration was essential to help clear the way for North Korea to offer its declaration and for President Bush to begin removing some sanctions against North Korea.

The United States also agreed to pay North Korea $2.5 million -- down from $5 million originally demanded by Pyongyang -- for the televised destruction last week of the steel-reinforced concrete cooling tower attached to the Yongbyon nuclear facility, congressional sources said. Officially, North Korea must still provide an itemized bill for the work, said to be technically difficult to avoid having pieces of the cooling tower fall into a nearby nuclear waste pond.

When the State Department announced in October that an agreement had been reached on receiving North Korea's declaration, it issued a "fact sheet" stating that North Korea had "agreed to provide a complete and correct declaration of all its nuclear programs -- including clarification regarding the uranium issue -- by the end of the year."

But sources said that within the closely held 60-page declaration, in which North Korea states it possesses 37 kilograms of plutonium, there is no discussion of the uranium issue, except for a brief reference to the U.S.-North Korean side deal on acknowledgments. The declaration provides a list of nuclear-related sites, but none are clearly identified as weapons sites.

"The declaration does reference the discussions that the United States had with North Korea on uranium enrichment and proliferation, but it is not appropriate for me to discuss the details at this time," said White House spokesman Gordon Johndroe.

The gap between the administration's initial objectives and the final results has led to sharp criticism in some quarters in Washington. "What we really have is sort of a Potemkin village of U.S. policy in which there's a great deal of difference between these initial bold pledges and then subsequent reality often behind the scenes," Bruce Klingner, a Korea expert at the Heritage Foundation, said yesterday at a forum to assess the deal.

The chief U.S. negotiator, Assistant Secretary of State Christopher R. Hill, acknowledged yesterday that the North Korea deal is "a partially finished product."

"We have to keep working on issues that have still not been fully disclosed, although not denied by the North Koreans," he said yesterday at the Center for International and Strategic Studies in Washington. But he emphasized that despite the unanswered questions about a uranium-enrichment program, the administration has succeeded in shutting down a dangerous nuclear reactor.

"It was less than a year ago that they were still producing plutonium, and plutonium is what they tested as a nuclear weapon," Hill said. "And plutonium is really, first of all, what we needed to stop their production of, and secondly, what we need to eventually have them abandon."

Uranium enrichment is a different route to producing the fuel for a nuclear weapon, and officials say that questions have only increased in recent weeks about the extent of North Korea's experimentation with the process.

Before acknowledging U.S. concerns, North Korea had consistently denied having any kind of enrichment program. But U.S. officials said traces of highly enriched uranium were recently discovered on some of the 18,000 pages of documents provided by North Korea on its plutonium program, heightening concerns. Hill also said the administration will continue to seek answers to North Korea's involvement in the construction of a nuclear reactor in Syria -- said to be modeled on Yongbyon -- which Israel destroyed last September.

Hill said the administration will spend the next week deciding on the "verification mechanism" to assess North Korea's claims in the declaration. Pyongyang has indicated it will allow visits to facilities, interviews with North Korea specialists, technical sampling and access to documents, so a major test of the accord will be whether North Korea balks at any requests the United States makes.

Last week, Bush set in motion a 45-day process under which North Korea will be removed from the list of state sponsors of terrorism. U.S. officials have suggested the process could be stopped if North Korea proves uncooperative, but few expect that verification of North Korea's declaration will be completed before the 45-day period ends in mid-August.

Everyone gains if Syria returns to the centre of the Arab world

Sphere: Related Content
The Nation

Everyone gains if Syria returns to the centre of the Arab world

Mohamad Bazzi, Edward R. Murrow Press Fellow
June 18. 2008

For decades, Syria has portrayed itself as the "beating heart of Arab nationalism" - the torchbearer of resistance and defiance to the West. That stance has often put Damascus at odds with other Arab regimes, especially those allied with the United States. But Syria managed to keep a central role in Arab politics.

After the US invasion of Iraq in 2003, the Bush administration turned its attention to Syria as another candidate for "regime change". The Syrian regime meddled in Iraq, nurtured Palestinian militants opposed to peace with Israel and dominated its smaller neighbour, Lebanon. For a country that is not rich in oil and has little economic clout, Syria derived its power from its strategic position in the Middle East. As the US sought to isolate Damascus, some Arab powers - especially Saudi Arabia - became hostile to the Syrian president, Bashar Assad, and his growing reliance on Iran. Syria was excluded from the Arab "fold".

But the balance of power in the region has shifted in recent months, and Arab governments are once again wooing Syria. Qatar and Egypt, in particular, want to end Syria's isolation and are working to improve Saudi-Syrian relations. Assad enhanced his position in the region by strongly backing Hizbollah in the Lebanese conflict and by agreeing to indirect talks with Israel through Turkish mediators.

Syria has played the role of a regional spoiler since 1970, when Hafez Assad rose to power in a military coup. He perfected the art of shifting alliances, stirring up trouble in neighbouring countries, and keeping his enemies mired in costly battles. When Assad died in June 2000, he was succeeded by his son, Bashar, a soft-spoken, British-educated ophthalmologist who had little experience in the hard-knuckled politics of the Middle East. While many dismissed the younger Assad as incapable of balancing his regional cards as masterfully as his father, Bashar has grown into the role of strongman over the past seven years.

After Saddam Hussein's removal, the Bush administration accused Syria of sheltering Iraqi Baathist leaders and allowing Islamic militants to slip into Iraq to fight US forces. In 2004, president George W Bush imposed economic sanctions against Damascus and tried to isolate it. That policy accelerated after the assassination of the former Lebanese prime minister, Rafik Hariri, in February 2005, in which top Syrian officials have been implicated by a United Nations investigation.

In response to America's cold shoulder, Assad's regime became more dependent on Iran (a partnership began in the early 1980s under the elder Assad), which helped shore up the Syrian economy with construction investments and cheap oil. Damascus also enhanced its alliances with Hamas, Hizbollah and the renegade Iraqi Shiite cleric Muqtada al Sadr. Assad knows the US cannot find a way out of Iraq without his help, but just to be safe, he keeps his connections to Hamas, Hizbollah and Sadr as potential bargaining chips that can shape events in the Palestinian territories, Lebanon and Iraq.


Assad's main goal is to preserve his Alawite minority regime that rules a Sunni-dominated country (the Alawites are an offshoot of Shiite Islam). But the holy grail for Assad - as for his father before him - is to regain control of the Golan Heights, a strategic terrain Israel occupied during the 1967 Six Day war.

Turkish mediators announced on Monday that Israeli and Syrian officials had completed two days of indirect talks, with another round set for July. Unlike the weak Palestinian leader, Mahmoud Abbas, Assad can actually deliver on a peace deal with Israel. Syria has consistently said that full peace is possible, but only if every inch of the Golan is returned. In January 2000, the then US president Bill Clinton led marathon talks between Hafez Assad and Ehud Barak, the then Israeli prime minister. Those discussions collapsed over a sliver of land, about 100 metres wide, that would have given Syria access to the Sea of Galilee, a major source of water for Israel.

Even without a regional settlement, Israel has much to gain from a deal over the Golan. It would mean not only a peace treaty with Syria, but an end of Syrian aid to what is now Israel's most dangerous enemy: Hizbollah, the Shiite militia that did surprisingly well in its war with a far superior Israeli army in the summer of 2006.

In addition to supporting renewed talks over the Golan, Washington must send its ambassador (who was recalled after the Hariri assassination) back to Damascus and resume high-level contact with Syrian officials. The Bush administration should also abandon its calls for a new government in Damascus.

Regime change is wishful thinking. Thanks to the Iraq war, Assad is now stronger than ever. Sadly, for Syrians worried about the carnage in Iraq, the Baathist dictatorship offers security, even as it arrests democracy activists and stifles the few freedoms Syrians still have.

By restarting dialogue, the US and Syria can find some common ground. For example, Syria favours a strong central government in Baghdad, while Iran does not. The Syrians are worried about the leakage that would be caused by a weak central state in Iraq. (Already, Syria is dealing with an influx of about 1.5 million Iraqi refugees, who are causing tremendous economic, social and security pressures.) That is one major area where Syrian and Iranian interests diverge - and the US and its Arab allies can take advantage of it.

The Syrian-Iranian alliance has endured for more than 25 years; it cannot be undone quickly. But the US and Arab regimes can begin to woo Syria away.

Mohamad Bazzi is the Edward R Murrow Press Fellow at the US Council on Foreign Relations and is an assistant professor of journalism at New York University.

Washington’s Policy of Isolating Syria Hurting U.S. Interests

Sphere: Related Content
Council on Foreign Relations

Washington’s Policy of Isolating Syria Hurting U.S. Interests, says Council Special Report

June 25, 2008
Washington's attempt to isolate and undermine the Assad regime has largely failed, concludes a new Council Special Report. The Bush administration's policy of "new economic sanctions, a diplomatic boycott, and increasing contacts with the Syrian opposition," has not compelled Damascus to "change course and comply with Washington’s…demands."

Instead, the authors, Mona Yacoubian and Scott Lasensky of the U.S. Institute of Peace, advocate working with Syria where U.S. and Syrian interests may overlap. They argue that "the benefits of engagement with Syria are derivative of broader U.S. goals in the region:" seeking stability in Iraq and Lebanon, promoting peace and stability between Israel and its Arab neighbors, and heading off Iranian influence. They explain that "engagement with the Syrians would rely on a variety of diplomatic tools…balancing rewards for sustained cooperation with severe consequences for continued Syrianintransigence."

The report, Dealing with Damascus: Seeking a Greater Return on U.S.-Syria Relations,outlines the potential gains from engagement on these core issues:

Iraq: “The Syrians could agree to implement sustained measures to stave the flow of arms and insurgents, including tighter border controls and visa restrictions at the Damascus airport, in exchange for a significant infusion of U.S. aid to help provide for Iraqi refugees in Syria.”

Lebanon: “In the short term, the United States…should work with the Syrians and others to ensure the success of Lebanon’s Qatar-brokered political compromise between the governing March 14th coalition and the Hezbollah-led opposition….While the longer-term implications of the agreement are still unclear, Syria’s willingness to work with the United States and its European allies to make sure that Lebanon does not fall back into crippling instability would serve as an important gauge of Syria’s intentions.”

Arab-Israeli process: “[Washington] should also support and seek a direct role in renewed Syria-Israel peace negotiations, both as a confidence-building measure to signal Damascus about Washington’s seriousness regarding engagement, as well as to tee up the next set of issues for discussion.”

Iran: “Syria’s national interests do not coincide completely with those of Iran. First, Syria’s ties to Iran put it at odds with its Arab allies, thus damaging its Arab nationalist credentials. Second, unlike Iran, Syria seeks to engage Israel…. Third, even in Iraq, Syria’s interests may diverge from Iran’s over the long run when an eventual U.S. withdrawal could turn Iraq into an arena of competition rather than cooperation between Syria and Iran. U.S. engagement with Syria on a variety of issues may leverage Syria’s divergent interests with Iran toward a greater convergence of interests with the United States....Furthermore, these benefits would most likely come following successful engagement with the Syrians on other issues (e.g., Iraq, Israel). In particular, movement toward a peaceful resolution of the Syria-Israel conflict would likely result in a distancing between Syria and its Iranian ally, by removing a key item from their shared anti-Western agenda—conflict with Israel.”

The report concludes that the United States faces two crucial choices regarding its policy toward Syria: “continued isolation or serious engagement.” Ultimately, the authors argue that conditional engagement is likely to further U.S. interests in the region.

الأربعاء، 2 يوليو 2008

انعطافة ايجابية: الحكومة اللبنانية في ساعات؟!

Sphere: Related Content
اثمرت زيارة رئيس كتلة "المستقبل" النائب سعد الحريري للقصر الجهوري ليل امس الثلاثاء، اعادة التواصل بين السرايا الحكومية والرابية في انتظار اتصال مباشر بين قريطم والرابية، وكذلك في اتجاه قوى بارزة في المعارضة، في ظل معطيات اقليمية ودولية تصب في خانة التشجيع على تأليف الحكومة سريعا.
وزار المسؤول عن الاتصالات السياسية في "التيار الوطني الحر" جبران باسيل السرايا الحكومية بعد ظهر اليوم، في اشارة الى اعادة الحرارة على خط التواصل بين الرئيس المكلف تشكيل الحكومة فؤاد السنيورة ورئيس تكتل "الاصلاح والتغيير" النائب العماد ميشال عون.
وذكرت مصادر نيابية في التكتل أن اجتماع السنيورة بباسيل كان ايجابيًّا جدًّا، كاشفة عن احتمال ولادة الحكومة في الساعات الاربع والعشرين المقبلة.
واشارت الى أن السنيورة عرض على باسيل وزارات الطاقة والنفط، والأشغال العامّة، والاقتصاد، والزراعة، إضافة الى منصب نائب رئيس مجلس الوزراء.
وعلق قيادي كبير في الموالاة، لافتا الى ان "العرض سخي في حال صح هذا الكلام"، خصوصا ان "جمع وزارتي الاشغال والاقتصاد يجعل سلة العماد عون "ثرية ومليئة".

تأثيرات تعثر تشكيل الحكومة على ساركوزي والاسد وعلى زيارة سليمان لباريس

Sphere: Related Content قال ديبلوماسي غربي رفيع عامل في بيروت ان استمرار عرقلة او تعثر ولادة حكومة الوحدة الوطنية سيؤثر حكما على كل من زيارتي رئيس الجمهورية العماد ميشال سليمان والرئيس السوري بشار الاسد لباريس، وان من منطلقين مختلفين، كما سيكون له مضاعفات فرنسية واوروبية على الرئيس نيكولا ساركوزي نفسه الذي احرج كثيرا عند تعميم خبر مشاركة الاسد في ذكرى الثورة الفرنسية لولا الاخراج الذي لجأ اليه فريق عمله، مع السعي الى التركيز على اهمية التقاء الاسد برئيس الوزراء الاسرائيلي ايهوج اولمرت، في محاولة لتحوير الاهتمام عن وقوفه الى جانب الاسد في العرض العسكري التقليدي عند جادة الشانزيلزيه.
ولفت الى ان زيارة وزير الخارجية السوري وليد المعلم للعاصمة الفرنسية وادراج لقاء له مع ساركوزي من المفترض ان يعقد بعد غد الجمعة، اضافة الى اللقاء مع وزير الخارجية برنار كوشنير، مرتبط مباشرة في الوضع اللبناني، وسيقول فيه ساركوزي كلاما واضحا حول الاستقرار السياسي والامني، وسيحرص على ان تكون عباراته حاسمة وحازمة كي تنقل بوضوح الى الرئيس السوري.
واوضح انه فهم من مصادر رسمية لبنانية ان زيارة الرئيس سليمان لباريس مرتبطة جذريا بمآل الشأن الحكومي، وهو بات يفضل ان يعتر عن عدم الذهاب في حال استمر تعثر ولادة الحكوة، لانه يفضل ان يكون ظهوره الرسمي والبروتوكولي الاول خارج لبنان كامل الصفات والاوصاف، بمعنى ان هذه الاطلالة الدولية الاولى يجب ان تكون كاملة في الشكل وفي المضمون، فيترأس سليمان الوفد الرئاسي اللبناني الى جانب رئيس الحكومة العتيدة والوزراء المعنيين، والا فمن الافضل الاعتذار.

الثلاثاء، 1 يوليو 2008

جهود تشكيل الحكومة في "نقطة ميتة" ولا تقدم قبل 5 تموز

Sphere: Related Content
كشف مصدر سياسي رفيع ان المساعي الرامية الى تشكيل الحكومة لا تزال في "نقطة ميتة"، اي في المكان الذي انتهت فيه الجمعة الفائت على اثر سحب الرئيس المكلف تشكيل الحكومة فؤاد السنيورة اقتراحه على رئيس تكتل "الاصلاح والتغيير" النائب العماد ميشال عون. واوضح ان عدم تقدم الاتصالات والمشاورات يعني ان العماد عون، على الرغم من رسائل اللين الذي ضمنها مؤتمره الصحافي امس الاول في الرابية، لا يزال عند مطلبه بحقيبة سيادية وحقيبة الأشغال العامة إضافة الى وزارتي الشؤون الإجتماعية والزراعة، وهو امر يبدو صعب التحقق سياسيا كما لوجستيا لجهة التوازن في توزيع الحقائب. ولاحظ ان رئيس مجلس النواب نبيه بري غادر بيروت بالتزامن مع عودة العماد عون الى المطالبة بوزارة سيادية، هي نظريا من حصة رئيس البرلمان.
وتوقع ان يستمر الجمود الحكومي الى ما بعد الرابع من تموز، موعد ولادة اللقاء الوطني المسيحي، مشيرا الى ان واقع الحال يفرض الاستنتاج ان عون لن يقدم على اي تنازل فعلي قبل اطلاق الورقة التأسيسية لهذا اللقاء. ورأى ان الحراك الفعلي سيكون بين الخامس من تموز والثاني عشر منه، في الفترة الذي سيكون على الرئيس السوري بشار الاسد اثبات حسن النية تجاه باريس قبل زيارتها للمشاركة في احتفالات ذكرى الثورة الفرنسية.

عون لم يفاتح بأي صيغة حكومية جديدة

Sphere: Related Content
نفى رئيس تكتل "الاصلاح والتغيير" النائب العماد ميشال عون ان يكون قد عُرضت عليه اي صيغة حكومية، خلافا لما ورد في عدد من الصحف.
ونقل زوار الرابية مساء اليوم ان عون صارحهم بأنه لم يطلع على اي صيغة جديدة، وان جلّ ما قيل عن حصول التكتل على وزارتي الاتصالات والأشغال العامة اضافة الى نيابة رئاسة الحكومة وزارة دولة في مقابل تخليه عن وزارة الشؤون الاجتماعية، هو كلام اعلامي اطلع عليه في احدى الصحف، ولم يفاتحه احد به لا في الموالاة ولا في المعارضة.